|Joan Watson and Sherlock Holmes: Elementary|
CBS's new hour long drama Elementary has all the elements of good television. Starring Jonny Lee Miller as a modern Sherlock Holmes who uses his genius to solve crimes and Lucy Liu as Joan Watson, his sobriety partner, Elementary places the two character in present day New York. The series premiered Thursday, with a good (not great) episode. Miller played Holmes with an interesting mix of neurosis and charisma. His chemistry with Lucy Liu was intriguing. When he interrupts Watson at an Opera, refusing to be quiet until she acknowledges him, I saw a flash of the unique potential friendship/codependency.
That was just it though. I saw potential. The actual mystery wasn't very interesting. It never invested me in the crime or the characters like BBC's truly masterful modern spin on Sherlock's tales entitled quite simply Sherlock and starring Benedict Cumberbatch as the title character. I really like Sherlock's stories, and really want to like Elementary. If however, the crimes grow too...well, CBS procedural, I may not stick around. The premiere did tantalize a backstory about something going terribly wrong in London, causing Sherlock to relocate and spiral into addiction. If the show delves into that very interesting backstory and raids from the classic Sherlock mysteries and character, I will absolutely watch it, enjoying it as a different spin on a truly mysterious and wonderful man. For now, Sherlock is still my favorite version, but I'm willing to cheat on it. That is, if Miller gets a better scarf. Seriously. What do you call that pattern? Rainbow plaid?